Bad Breaker, Signs, Causes And Repair

Circuit breaker plays an important role in the safety of our daily life because it protects electrical equipment and devices against short circuit and overload faults.

The normal life of a standard circuit breaker is up to forty years. However, sometimes faults occur and a breaker goes bad.

In this article, I will discuss the reasons, signs, and testing methods of bad circuit breakers.

Table of Contents

What does a bad breaker mean?

A bad breaker typically refers to a malfunctioning electrical circuit breaker, which is an important safety device in your home’s electrical system.

Circuit breakers are designed to automatically shut off electrical flow when they detect an overload or a short circuit, thus preventing potential electrical fires or other hazards.

When a breaker is considered “bad,” it often implies that it is not functioning properly. This can manifest in several ways:

Constant Tripping: If the breaker is tripping frequently even when the electrical load is within its capacity, it might indicate a faulty breaker.
Inability to Reset: A breaker that refuses to reset or stays in the tripped position might suggest internal damage or a malfunction.
Physical Damage: Visual signs of damage such as burns, corrosion, or a warped appearance can indicate a problem with the breaker.
Inconsistent Power Supply: If a particular circuit is not consistently delivering power, it could be due to a malfunctioning breaker.

A bad breaker can pose serious safety risks, including electrical fires or damage to appliances. It’s crucial to address any issues with your electrical system promptly.

If you suspect a bad breaker, it is advisable to consult a qualified electrician for an assessment and potential replacement. Trying to fix electrical issues without proper knowledge can be dangerous and is not recommended.

Can a circuit breaker wear out?

Yes, circuit breakers can wear out over time. While they are designed to be durable and long-lasting, they are not immune to the effects of wear and tear. Several factors can contribute to the degradation of a circuit breaker:

Age: Over time, the internal components of a circuit breaker can deteriorate, leading to decreased effectiveness and reliability. Older circuit breakers may be more prone to wearing out compared to newer ones.
Frequent Tripping: If a circuit breaker trips often due to frequent power surges or overloads, it can accelerate the wear on its internal mechanisms. Constant tripping can cause damage to the internal components and decrease the lifespan of the breaker.
Environmental Factors: Harsh environmental conditions such as high humidity, extreme temperatures, or exposure to chemicals can contribute to the degradation of the circuit breaker’s components over time.
Poor Maintenance: Lack of proper maintenance or neglecting to address electrical issues promptly can lead to the deterioration of the circuit breaker.

When a circuit breaker wears out, it may become less reliable in tripping during overloads or short circuits, potentially compromising the safety of your electrical system.

Periodic inspection and maintenance by a qualified electrician can help identify any signs of wear and prevent potential hazards. If you suspect that your circuit breaker is wearing out or malfunctioning, it is crucial to have it inspected and, if necessary, replaced by a professional electrician.

I’ve written a detailed article about circuit breaker tripping, you can read it here for more information.

Should I replace A tripped circuit breaker?

If a circuit breaker trips, it is important to first identify the cause of the trip. The tripping of a circuit breaker is often a safety feature, designed to protect your home’s electrical system from potential overloads or short circuits that could lead to electrical fires or other hazards.

Here are the steps to follow when a circuit breaker trips:

Identify the Cause: Determine which electrical appliance or device may have caused the overload or short circuit. Unplug or turn off the device before attempting to reset the breaker.
Reset the Breaker: After identifying and addressing the cause of the overload, you can attempt to reset the tripped breaker. To do this, switch the breaker to the “off” position and then back to the “on” position.
Monitor the Situation: Observe whether the breaker holds and the power remains stable. If the breaker continues to trip repeatedly, it may indicate a more serious issue with the circuit or the breaker itself.
Seek Professional Assistance: If the breaker keeps tripping or if you notice any signs of damage, it is advisable to consult a qualified electrician. They can assess the situation, identify the root cause, and determine whether the breaker needs to be replaced.

In most cases, simply resetting a tripped circuit breaker is sufficient. However, if the breaker continues to trip frequently or if you suspect there is an underlying electrical issue, it is crucial to consult a professional electrician to ensure the safety and functionality of your electrical system.

They can provide expert guidance on whether the circuit breaker needs replacement or if there are any other necessary repairs.

why does my breaker keep tripping?

A circuit breaker can trip for several reasons, and it’s important to identify the cause to prevent damage to your electrical system and ensure the safety of your home. Some common reasons why your breaker keeps tripping include:

Overloaded Circuit: An overloaded circuit, which occurs when the electrical load exceeds the breaker’s capacity, can cause the breaker to trip as a safety measure.
Short Circuit: A short circuit, often caused by a hot wire coming into contact with a neutral wire or ground wire, can lead to a sudden surge of current and cause the breaker to trip.
Ground Fault: A ground fault, where a hot wire comes into contact with a ground wire or a metal box, can cause the breaker to trip as well.
Faulty Appliances: A malfunctioning or faulty appliance can create an electrical issue that causes the breaker to trip.
Aging Breaker: Over time, breakers can wear out and become more sensitive, leading them to trip more frequently.

For more information read my article, Breaker Keeps Tripping?

My circuit breaker is stuck in the middle! What does it mean?

If your circuit breaker is stuck in the middle position, it generally indicates a problem. A circuit breaker has three positions: “on,” “off,” and a center position that indicates a tripped state. When it’s stuck in the middle, it suggests that the breaker has tripped but hasn’t fully switched to the “off” position.

Here are a few possible reasons why your circuit breaker is stuck in the middle:

Electrical Overload: The circuit breaker may have tripped due to an electrical overload, causing it to get stuck in the middle position as a safety measure.
Short Circuit: A short circuit in the electrical system can also cause the breaker to trip and get stuck in the middle position.
Mechanical Issue: There could be a mechanical issue within the breaker itself, preventing it from fully resetting to the “off” position.

Here’s what you can do to address the issue:

Identify the Problem: Try to identify the possible cause of the tripped breaker, such as an overloaded circuit or a short circuit.
Turn it Off: If the breaker is stuck in the middle, attempt to push it firmly to the “off” position. However, it’s important to handle this with caution and avoid using excessive force, as this could potentially cause further damage.
Investigate the Cause: Once the breaker is in the “off” position, investigate the potential cause of the tripping, such as an appliance overloading the circuit or a short circuit.
Consult a Professional: If the breaker remains stuck or if you’re uncertain about the cause, it’s essential to contact a licensed electrician to inspect and address the issue. Attempting to fix electrical problems without the necessary expertise can be hazardous.

Always prioritize safety when dealing with electrical issues. If you’re unsure of what to do, it’s best to seek professional help to ensure that the problem is properly diagnosed and resolved.

For more about short circuits, read my detailed article here.

How can I tell if a breaker is bad without a multi-meter?

When a circuit breaker goes bad, it trips regularly, has smoke on its body, has a clear melted terminal, or when you check its voltage with an AVO-meter while it is in the ON position you will find no output power.

Another way is to isolate the CB input terminals and use the multi-meter as a buzzer to verify the continuity of each phase in both On and Off positions, I don’t have to tell you that in the off position, it should not buzz. If it’s bad, it most likely will buzz in the Off.

I can’t count the number of bad circuit breakers I have seen during my work as an electrical maintenance engineer.

The first sign of a bad circuit breaker I notice is smoke on its body.

Then, comes the melted breaker body. I don’t even have to use a multimeter to check a bad breaker with these clear damage signs.

I don’t even try to fix it. Replacing bad CB is the only direct solution.

Keep in mind that CB is a protection device to protect against short circuits and overcurrent.

In normal conditions, the CB connects power from the source to the load side. In fault conditions, the CB must trip immediately.

Fault conditions like short-circuited appliances, cords, or overloaded circuits. The point is not every tripping condition is a sign of a bad CB.

To know if the CB is bad or the circuit has a fault, I isolate the wiring from the output side of the breaker and then connect it to the ON position, If it trips then it’s a bad one.

Hint: If a CB tripped due to large amount of current i.e short circuit or overload, it will be hot, and will not accept the ON position until its temperature decrease. Don’t reset it immediately.

Signs of bad breakers you can recognize without a multimeter!

While a multimeter is a valuable tool for diagnosing electrical issues, there are some signs of bad breakers that you can recognize without using one. Here are some common signs that may indicate a faulty circuit breaker:

Frequent Tripping: If the breaker frequently trips, especially when it shouldn’t be under excessive load, it could indicate a problem.
Burning Smell: A burning smell coming from the breaker panel or anywhere near electrical outlets could suggest an electrical issue, potentially caused by a faulty breaker.
Visible Damage: Look for any visible signs of damage, such as frayed wires, burn marks, or discoloration around the circuit breaker.
Buzzing Sounds: If you hear unusual buzzing or humming sounds coming from the breaker panel, it could indicate loose connections or faulty components.
Hot Breaker Panel: A breaker panel that feels excessively hot to the touch might indicate an overloaded circuit or a malfunctioning breaker.
Flickering Lights: If lights flicker or dim without any apparent reason, it could indicate an issue with the electrical supply, potentially caused by a bad breaker.
Tripped Breaker Won’t Reset: If a tripped breaker refuses to reset or stays in the tripped position, it is likely malfunctioning and may need to be replaced.

If you notice any of these signs, it is essential to address the issue promptly to prevent potential electrical hazards.

Contact a licensed electrician for a professional assessment and resolution of the problem. Avoid attempting any repairs or replacements without proper knowledge and training, as it can be hazardous. Always prioritize safety when dealing with electrical issues in your home or building.

Can a bad breaker cause power surges

A bad breaker itself is not typically the cause of power surges. However, a malfunctioning breaker can potentially contribute to electrical issues that may result in power surges. Here are some ways in which a faulty breaker could indirectly lead to power surges:

Frequent Tripping: A bad breaker that frequently trips without apparent cause can disrupt the normal flow of electricity, potentially leading to power surges in the connected circuits.
Overloaded Circuits: If a breaker is unable to handle the electrical load due to internal damage or malfunction, it can cause the circuit to overload, resulting in power surges.
Voltage Fluctuations: A malfunctioning breaker might not regulate the voltage properly, leading to fluctuations in the electrical supply, which can result in power surges.
Electrical Arcing: A faulty breaker can create electrical arcing within the electrical panel, leading to sudden increases in voltage and power surges.

It’s important to address any issues with your circuit breaker promptly to prevent potential electrical problems, including power surges.

What causes a circuit breaker to go bad?

There are three main reasons for a bad CB. It is either due to:

Several factors can contribute to a circuit breaker going bad or becoming faulty. Understanding these factors can help you take preventative measures and maintain the integrity of your electrical system. Some common causes include:

Overloading: Excessive electrical loads on a circuit can cause the breaker to trip frequently, leading to wear and tear on its internal components. Continuous overloading can eventually lead to the breaker going bad. I have written a detailed article about OverCurrent you can check it out for more information.
Age: Like most electrical components, circuit breakers have a limited lifespan. With age, the internal components may deteriorate, leading to malfunctions or complete failure.
Environmental Factors: Harsh environmental conditions such as high humidity, extreme temperatures, or exposure to chemicals can contribute to the degradation of the circuit breaker’s components over time.
Manufacturing Defects: In some cases, a circuit breaker may have inherent defects from the manufacturing process, leading to early failure or malfunction.
Frequent Power Surges: Repeated power surges, either from the utility provider or internal electrical devices, can strain the circuit breaker, causing it to wear out over time.
Physical Damage: Physical damage to the circuit breaker, such as from accidents, improper handling, or exposure to water, can compromise its functionality and lead to failure.
Poor Maintenance: Lack of proper maintenance, such as neglecting to address electrical issues promptly or not conducting regular inspections, can lead to the deterioration of the circuit breaker.
Loosen-connected wiring: Loose wiring connections can also contribute to circuit breaker issues and lead to various problems within an electrical system. When wiring connections are not properly secured, several issues can arise.

Understanding these causes can help you implement best practices for maintaining your electrical system, such as avoiding overloading circuits, scheduling regular inspections, and addressing electrical issues promptly.

If you suspect a problem with your circuit breaker, it is advisable to consult a qualified electrician for a professional assessment and any necessary repairs or replacements.

Always tighten the connection terminals well — Bad Breaker Due to Loose wiring connections

Is a bad breaker dangerous?

Yes, a bad breaker can indeed be dangerous. A malfunctioning circuit breaker can compromise the safety of your electrical system and pose various risks, including:

Electrical Fires: A faulty circuit breaker may fail to trip during an overload or short circuit, potentially leading to overheating and electrical fires.
Electrical Hazards: Malfunctioning breakers can cause electrical shocks, especially if they fail to cut off power during a fault, posing a risk to anyone coming into contact with the electrical system.
Appliance Damage: Inconsistent or fluctuating electrical supply due to a bad breaker can damage connected appliances, leading to costly repairs or replacements.
Power Outages: A malfunctioning breaker can cause frequent power outages, disrupting daily activities and potentially causing damage to electronic devices or appliances.

To ensure the safety of your home and its occupants, it’s crucial to address any issues with your circuit breakers promptly.

Regular inspections by a qualified electrician can help identify potential problems and ensure that your electrical system is functioning properly.

If you suspect a bad breaker or notice any signs of electrical issues, it’s essential to consult a professional electrician for a thorough assessment and necessary repairs or replacements.

Avoid attempting any repairs yourself, as dealing with electrical systems without the proper knowledge and expertise can be hazardous.

Can you fix a bad circuit breaker and reuse it?

In general, it is not recommended to attempt to fix a bad circuit breaker on your own. Circuit breakers are intricate electrical components that require specific expertise to repair properly.

Additionally, tampering with electrical equipment without the necessary knowledge and training can be dangerous and can potentially lead to electrical hazards or further damage to the breaker or the electrical system.

If you suspect that a circuit breaker is not functioning correctly, it’s best to consult a licensed electrician for a professional assessment. The electrician can determine whether the circuit breaker can be repaired or if it needs to be replaced.

In some cases, simple issues such as a tripped breaker due to an overload or a short circuit can be resolved by resetting the breaker. However, if the breaker continues to malfunction or shows signs of damage, it’s essential to have it inspected by a professional.

They can provide guidance on the best course of action, which may involve replacing the breaker to ensure the safety and efficiency of your electrical system.

Remember that the safety of your home and its occupants is paramount when dealing with electrical systems. Always prioritize safety and consult a qualified professional for any electrical repairs or replacements.

Can a breaker go bad and still work?

If a circuit breaker goes bad, it can fail to function as expected, yet in exceptional circumstances, it may continue to conduct electricity to the load even when switched off. However, this unanticipated operation does not ensure the circuit’s protection.

Moreover, despite being operational, a malfunctioning circuit breaker cannot guarantee the anticipated safeguarding of the circuit. Often, once the circuit breaker deteriorates, it ceases to provide power, resulting in a loss of power to the circuit. Replacement becomes the sole option in such instances.

However, it is crucial to first examine the circuit, wiring, and loads for potential faults. If any faults are identified within the circuit, they should be repaired before checking the circuit breaker for normal operation.

Occasionally, a faulty 3-phase circuit breaker might be found in the off position, with only one phase conducting electricity. This intricate situation can be hazardous and demands careful handling.

That’s why I never rely on switching a circuit breaker OFF to isolate power before doing maintenance work. Instead, I double-check power isolation using a Multi-meter.

For more information about How to safely perform Electrical Isolation, read my article here.

Can a bad circuit breaker cause a low voltage?

Yes, a bad circuit breaker can potentially cause low voltage issues within an electrical system. When a circuit breaker malfunctions, it can lead to various electrical irregularities, including voltage fluctuations. Here are a few ways a faulty circuit breaker can contribute to low voltage:

Increased Resistance: A bad circuit breaker can create increased resistance in the electrical circuit, resulting in voltage drops and consequently causing low voltage issues.
Intermittent Contact: Faulty connections within the circuit breaker can lead to intermittent contact, causing fluctuations in the voltage supply and resulting in low voltage levels.
Overheating and Voltage Loss: Malfunctioning circuit breakers can overheat and lose their ability to manage and distribute voltage effectively, leading to low voltage supply to connected devices or appliances.
Tripping Issues: If a circuit breaker is tripping frequently due to internal faults, it can disrupt the flow of voltage to the connected circuit, causing low voltage problems.

While a bad circuit breaker can potentially lead to low voltage issues, it is essential to conduct a thorough examination of the entire electrical system to identify the root cause of the problem.

Consulting a qualified electrician is advisable for a comprehensive assessment and resolution of any electrical issues, including low voltage problems.

They can identify any faulty components, repair or replace them, and ensure the safe and efficient functioning of the electrical system.

My lights are flickering, Is it the circuit breaker?

Flickering lights can be caused by various issues within the electrical system, and while a faulty circuit breaker can be one of the causes, it is not necessarily the only reason. Here are some potential causes of flickering lights:

Loose Wiring: Loose wiring connections can result in intermittent power supply to the lights, causing them to flicker.
Overloaded Circuit: If the circuit is carrying more electrical load than it is designed for, it can cause the lights to flicker as it struggles to handle the demand.
Faulty Light Fixtures or Bulbs: Flickering lights can also be caused by issues within the light fixtures themselves or by faulty bulbs.
Voltage Fluctuations: Fluctuations in the voltage supplied to the lights can cause them to flicker. This can be due to various issues within the electrical system.
Issues with the Electrical Panel: Problems within the electrical panel, including a faulty circuit breaker, can result in flickering lights.

If you’re experiencing flickering lights, it’s essential to address the issue promptly to ensure the safety and proper functioning of your electrical system.

Start by checking whether the issue is specific to one light fixture or if it affects multiple areas in your home.

If the problem persists or seems to be related to the electrical system, it is advisable to consult a licensed electrician.

They can identify the root cause of the flickering lights and provide the necessary repairs or replacements to ensure the safety and stability of your electrical system.

Can a bad breaker cause the neutral to get hot?

A bad breaker can potentially cause the neutral wire to get hot, although this situation is not typical.

When a breaker malfunctions, it can lead to various issues within the electrical system, including problems with the flow of current through the neutral wire. Here’s how a faulty breaker might contribute to the neutral wire getting hot:

Imbalanced Current: If the breaker fails to trip during an overload or short circuit, it can lead to an imbalance in the current flow between the hot and neutral wires, causing the neutral wire to carry more current than it is designed to handle.
Loose Connections: A faulty breaker can lead to loose connections within the electrical panel, causing increased resistance in the circuit. This increased resistance can result in heat buildup in the neutral wire.
Overheating Breaker: A malfunctioning breaker itself might generate excess heat, affecting the surrounding components, including the neutral wire.
Voltage Fluctuations: If the breaker is not regulating the voltage properly, it can lead to fluctuations in the electrical current, potentially causing the neutral wire to heat up.

If you suspect that the neutral wire is getting hot or that there is an issue with your circuit breaker, it is crucial to address the problem promptly.

Contact a qualified electrician to assess the situation, identify the root cause of the issue, and provide the necessary repairs or replacements to ensure the safety and proper functioning of your electrical system.

Can a power surge damage my circuit breaker?

Yes, power surges can potentially damage circuit breakers, especially if they are severe or prolonged.

Power surges are sudden, transient spikes in voltage that can occur due to lightning strikes, utility company issues, or electrical appliance malfunctions.

These surges can place significant stress on electrical components, including circuit breakers, and can lead to various forms of damage:

Internal Damage: Severe power surges can damage the internal components of a circuit breaker, compromising its ability to function properly.
Tripping Issues: Prolonged or repetitive power surges can cause a circuit breaker to trip frequently, leading to wear and tear on its internal mechanisms.
Overheating: Power surges can cause overheating within the electrical system, including the circuit breaker, potentially leading to internal damage or malfunction.
Arcing and Short Circuits: Intense power surges can create electrical arcing and short circuits within the circuit breaker, causing significant damage and potentially rendering the breaker inoperable.

To protect your electrical system from power surges, you can consider installing surge protectors at the main electrical panel or at individual outlets to help mitigate the impact of sudden voltage spikes.

Additionally, if you suspect that your circuit breaker has been damaged due to a power surge, it is advisable to consult a qualified electrician for an assessment and any necessary repairs or replacements. They can help ensure the safety and stability of your electrical system.

A short circuit causes a breaker to go bad

A short circuit is a common cause of circuit breaker trips and damage. They are also more dangerous. Any circuit breaker is designed with two currents, rated current and short circuit current.

If the current of the short circuit fault is much higher than the designed short circuit current of the circuit breaker, the breaker will go bad.

If the short circuit current is lower than the designed value of the circuit breaker, the breaker will trip safely. And you can reset it.

A short circuit can happen if a fault occurs in your electrical outlets and a live or neutral wire comes into contact with it. This can also occur if the wiring of an appliance, plug, or other device is damaged.

If You have no power, while the breaker doesn’t trip, what does it mean?

If you have no power in your home, but the circuit breaker doesn’t trip, it could indicate an issue with the electrical wiring or the main electrical panel. Several potential causes could lead to this situation:

Faulty Wiring: There might be a problem with the electrical wiring, such as a loose connection, a damaged wire, or a disconnected circuit.
Main Service Disruption: A power outage from the utility provider or an issue with the main electrical service can result in a loss of power without the circuit breaker tripping.
Faulty Breaker: While the breaker itself might not be tripping, it could still be malfunctioning and not effectively distributing power to the circuits.
Electrical Panel Issues: Problems with the main electrical panel, such as a faulty connection or damage to the panel, can result in a loss of power.

If you’re experiencing a complete power loss without any tripped breakers, it’s essential to follow these steps:

Check if your neighbors are also experiencing a power outage to determine if the issue is with the utility provider.
Verify that the main electrical panel is receiving power and that all the switches are in the “on” position.
If there are no apparent issues with the main electrical panel, consider consulting a licensed electrician to inspect your home’s electrical system. They can identify any wiring issues, electrical panel problems, or other potential causes of the power loss and recommend the necessary repairs or solutions.

Dealing with electrical systems can be dangerous, so it’s crucial to prioritize safety and consult a professional electrician for any electrical issues beyond basic troubleshooting.

Can a power outage damage a circuit breaker?

A standard power outage itself typically does not damage a circuit breaker. However, there are some circumstances during or after a power outage that could potentially lead to damage or issues with the circuit breaker:

Power Surges: If there are power surges when the electricity is restored after an outage, it can cause a sudden spike in voltage that may damage the circuit breaker.
Electrical Overload: Some homeowners might unknowingly overload their circuits when power is restored, which could lead to a tripped or damaged circuit breaker.
Electrical Fluctuations: In some cases, fluctuations in the electrical supply during the outage or restoration period can impact the circuit breaker’s functionality, especially if the electrical system is older or already vulnerable.

To protect your electrical system during a power outage and subsequent restoration, it’s advisable to:

Use surge protectors to safeguard sensitive electronic devices and appliances from power surges when the electricity returns.
Avoid overloading circuits by gradually reconnecting devices and appliances, especially power-hungry equipment like heaters, air conditioners, or refrigerators.
Consider installing a whole-house surge protector to provide comprehensive protection for your home’s electrical system.

If you suspect that a power outage has caused damage to your circuit breaker, or if you experience any issues with the electrical system after an outage, it’s crucial to consult a licensed electrician for a thorough assessment.

They can identify any potential damage and recommend the necessary repairs or replacements to ensure the safety and stability of your electrical system.

Don’t Leave Empty-Handed!

Install my Free Android App on Google Play:

Electrical Cables Most Common Tables “Cables Tables”

And, my Electrical Calculations App “Fast Electrical Calculator”

Discover more great content by subscribing to My channel

Looking to stay ahead of the game in the world of electrical engineering? Subscribe to my YouTube channel and gain access to exclusive content you won’t find anywhere else!

The staff I recommend

(Amazon Affiliate Links to products I believe are high quality):

Economy 120 Volt/60Hz AC Power Source – Step-Down Voltage & Frequency Converters 1800W
UNI-T Digital Multimeter Tester UT139C
50-Amp Extension Cord for RV “100ft”
Voltage Stabilizer 110/220v
Hair Dryer “best selling“
TOSHIBA EM131A5C-BS Countertop Microwave Ovens

Disclaimer: This contains affiliate links to Amazon products. I may earn a commission for purchases made through these links.