Blog

Universal motors have specific advantages and disadvantages, which make them suitable for certain applications while less appropriate for others. Here’s a breakdown of their advantages and disadvantages:

Advantages:

1. Versatility: Universal motors can operate on both AC and DC power sources, making them highly versatile. This versatility allows them to be used in a wide range of applications.

2. High Starting Torque: Universal motors provide high starting torque, making them suitable for applications that require rapid acceleration or high torque at startup. This characteristic is valuable in power tools, kitchen appliances, and vacuum cleaners.

3. Compact Size: Universal motors are relatively compact and lightweight, making them suitable for portable and space-constrained applications.

4. Variable Speed: Universal motors offer variable speed control, which is valuable in applications where adjustable speed is required, such as power tools and kitchen mixers.

5. Reversibility: Universal motors can easily change the direction of rotation by reversing the polarity of the applied voltage or by changing the direction of the current in the windings. This reversibility is a valuable feature in many applications.

Disadvantages:

1. Noise and Vibration: Universal motors tend to be noisy during operation due to the physical contact between brushes and the commutator. They can also generate vibrations, leading to a less pleasant operating environment.

2. Brush Wear: Universal motors rely on brushes that make contact with the commutator. These brushes experience wear over time and may require periodic replacement, which can be considered a maintenance drawback.

3. Lower Efficiency: Universal motors are less efficient than some other motor types, particularly at high speeds and under heavy loads. They may generate heat and consume more energy.

4. Limited Lifespan: Due to brush wear and other factors, universal motors typically have a limited lifespan compared to brushless motor types. This can result in the need for motor replacement or maintenance.

5. Limited Use in High-Precision Applications: Universal motors may not be suitable for high-precision applications due to their inherent brush and commutator design, which can lead to slight variations in speed and torque.

6. Heat Generation: Universal motors tend to generate heat, especially under heavy loads or extended operation, which can impact efficiency and may require additional cooling mechanisms.

In summary, universal motors are valuable for applications that prioritize high starting torque, variable speed control, and compact size.

However, their noise, maintenance requirements, and lower efficiency can be drawbacks in some situations.

The choice of motor type depends on the specific requirements and constraints of the application in which it will be used.
Stan Zurek, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Universal motors achieve high speeds due to their design, variable voltage capability, and high torque-to-inertia ratio.

Their lack of synchronous speed limitations, efficient commutation, and compact size contribute to rapid acceleration.

However, high speed may come with increased noise and heat, and maintenance may be required due to brush wear.

A universal motor can operate on both AC (alternating current) and DC (direct current) due to its unique design and the nature of how it generates rotational motion. Here’s a detailed explanation:

Series-Wound Configuration

In a universal motor, the armature winding (rotor) and the field winding (stator) are connected in series. This design is key to its ability to work on both AC and DC.

• DC Operation: When DC is applied, a unidirectional current flows through both the field winding and the armature, creating magnetic fields that interact to produce torque and rotation.

• AC Operation: When AC is applied, the current alternates direction. However, since the field and armature windings are in series, the magnetic fields in both reverse simultaneously. The torque generated remains in the same direction, allowing the motor to continue rotating smoothly.

Synchronous Reversal of Magnetic Fields

With AC, both the field and armature magnetic fields reverse polarity at the same time. This synchronous reversal ensures that the direction of the torque remains constant, preventing the motor from stalling or reversing direction with every half cycle of AC.

Commutator and Brushes

The universal motor uses a commutator and brushes to manage the flow of current through the armature. The commutator switches the armature current direction in sync with the rotation, ensuring that the motor generates continuous torque, whether powered by AC or DC.

Advantages of This Dual Compatibility

• Versatility: The ability to operate on both AC and DC makes universal motors ideal for portable appliances and tools, which might use AC from the grid or DC from batteries.
• High Performance: They deliver high torque and speed regardless of the type of power supply, making them suitable for demanding applications like vacuum cleaners, drills, and mixers.

Why Other Motors Can’t Do This

Motors like induction motors rely on the phase difference in AC and don’t function with DC, while DC motors typically can’t handle the constantly reversing current of AC without complex modifications. The universal motor’s series-wound design and commutator system enable it to handle both smoothly.

This versatility is advantageous in applications where the type of power source may vary or where variable speed control and high starting torque are required, such as in power tools, kitchen appliances, and portable equipment.

However, it’s essential to note that the motor’s efficiency and performance characteristics may vary depending on the power source and load conditions.

A universal motor doesn’t require a capacitor because of its inherent design and operation, no phase shifting is required by a capacitor because both the field winding and the armature winding are energized in the same circuit.

Unlike some types of AC motors that use capacitors to create the necessary phase shift for starting and running, a universal motor operates differently.

A universal motor is essentially a DC series motor, which means it’s internally self-excited. This self-excitation occurs because both the field winding and the armature winding are energized in the same circuit, creating a magnetic field that drives the motor’s rotation. This setup eliminates the need for an external capacitor or any additional components to create the necessary phase shift in the current.

In other words, a universal motor doesn’t rely on the same principles as single-phase AC induction motors that use capacitors to create a rotating magnetic field for starting.

Instead, it’s more akin to a DC motor in terms of its electrical characteristics, with both field and armature windings being powered directly from the same source.

This self-excitation and the direct connection of windings make universal motors well-suited for applications where variable speed control and the ability to operate on both AC and DC power sources are needed, such as in vacuum cleaners, power tools, and appliances with variable speed settings.

Universal motors are known to produce sparks during operation, primarily due to the way they handle current and commutation. Here’s a detailed explanation of why this happens:

Brushes and Commutator Contact

• Universal motors use brushes that make contact with the commutator (a segmented rotary switch) to supply current to the rotating armature.
• As the armature rotates, the brushes slide over the commutator segments, switching the current direction in the armature windings to maintain torque.

Arcing During Commutation

• Arcing occurs when the brushes transition from one commutator segment to another.
• During this transition, the electrical contact momentarily breaks or weakens, but the motor’s inductance tries to maintain current flow. This results in a spark (arc) between the brush and the commutator.

High-Speed Operation

• Universal motors often run at high speeds, increasing the frequency of commutation.
• More frequent switching of current in the armature leads to a higher likelihood of sparking.

Inductive Kickback

• The motor’s windings have inductance, which resists changes in current. When the commutator segments switch, the rapid change in current causes a voltage spike (known as inductive kickback), contributing to sparking.

Worn Brushes or Commutator

• Over time, the brushes and commutator can wear out, increasing resistance at the contact points.
• Poor contact exacerbates sparking as the electrical connection becomes less stable.

Over time, this can affect the motor’s performance and efficiency and necessitate maintenance, including periodic replacement of brushes and, occasionally, commutator maintenance.